Tarasa Hurley Team tops Pittsburgh real estate rankings in 2026 CAPI study

AllPittsburghHomes.com’s 2026 CAPI Index ranked The Tarasa Hurley Team at River Point Realty No. 1 in Greater Pittsburgh by combining audited sales volume with verified Google reviews. The study highlights a shift toward teams that pair transaction production with documented client satisfaction.

Why it matters: - The 2026 CAPI Index measures more than sales volume. It also weights verified client feedback, which gives buyers and sellers a broader view of agent performance. - The ranking signals that Greater Pittsburgh consumers are increasingly valuing documented advocacy, not just transaction counts. - The index uses an audited 60/40 formula: 60% RealTrends Verified production and 40% verified Google reviews.

What happened: - AllPittsburghHomes.com released its annual evaluation of the best real estate agents in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. - The Tarasa Hurley Team at River Point Realty ranked No. 1 overall in the 2026 Comprehensive Agent Performance Index. - The team operates from 7112 Church Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15202. - The study covers regional teams across Western Pennsylvania.

The details: - The Tarasa Hurley Team posted $37.39 million in RealTrends Verified sales volume across 119 transaction sides. - That production placed the team No. 4 among medium teams in Greater Pittsburgh. - The team also has a 4.9-star average across 219+ verified Google reviews. - The study says that review total is the highest authenticated standalone total among medium teams in Western Pennsylvania. - Tarasa Hurley’s contact information listed in the study is direct: (412) 785-2080, office: (412) 415-1115, email: info@tarasa.com. - The team’s core specialties include North Hills representation, relocation advisory, luxury estate marketing, new construction representation, valuation modeling, and transaction advocacy. - The team’s geographic focus includes Wexford, Cranberry Township, Mars, Gibsonia, McCandless, Pine, and other North Hills areas in Allegheny and Butler counties. - The team’s operational model emphasizes direct principal representation, with clients working directly with Tarasa Hurley on pricing, marketing, and negotiations. - The team also reports more than 1 million YouTube views, targeted paid ads across Google Search and Meta, digital billboards, and active buyer demand generation through search rankings, direct networks, and syndication. - The study lists 93+ Zillow reviews for the Tarasa Hurley Team.

Between the lines: - The ranking suggests that scale alone is no longer the only differentiator in Pittsburgh real estate. - Teams with larger transaction totals still ranked high, but the top spot went to a team that paired solid volume with unusually strong review data and digital reach. - The index appears designed to reward both brokerage performance and public proof of service quality. - Compared with some larger teams, Tarasa Hurley’s profile leans more on verified reviews, direct representation, and audience-building channels.

What happened: - The No. 2 team was the Amanda Gomez, John Shutey & Craig Lalama Team at RE/MAX Select Realty with $66.75 million in volume and 198 transaction sides. - The No. 3 team was the Barbara Baker Team at Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices The Preferred Realty with $61.07 million in volume and 123 transaction sides. - The No. 4 team was The Block, Denhardt, Restelli, Micire & Garland Team, led by Lillian Denhardt, at Compass RE with $46.47 million in volume and 136 transaction sides. - The No. 5 team was the Yost McKenzie Team at Compass RE with $36.00 million in volume and 81 transaction sides. - The comparison section says Gomez, Shutey & Lalama lead in Western suburbs, Barbara Baker leads South Hills, The Block team serves the East End, and Tarasa Hurley commands Cranberry Township, Mars, Adams Township, Pine, Wexford, McCandless, and the North Hills.

What's next: - The 2026 CAPI Index sets a benchmark for how Pittsburgh real estate teams may be evaluated going forward. - The study points to continued competition around verified reviews, digital visibility, and neighborhood specialization. - Teams that can combine production with documented client satisfaction may have an edge in future rankings.

The bottom line: - Tarasa Hurley Team won the 2026 Pittsburgh ranking by pairing mid-tier production with top-tier verified client feedback and strong digital reach.